Mille neuf cent quatre-vingt-quatre

450 pages

Langue : French

Publié 3 novembre 2021 par Agone.

ISBN :
978-2-7489-0446-8
Copied ISBN!

Voir sur Inventaire

5 étoiles (2 critiques)

« Le pouvoir nous enseigne à rejeter l’évidence de nos yeux et de nos oreilles. C’est son commandement ultime, le plus essentiel. Winston sentit son cœur lui manquer à la pensée de la puissance démesurée qui était déployée contre lui, à la facilité avec laquelle n’importe quel intellectuel le remettrait à sa place avec des arguments subtils qu’il serait incapable de comprendre, et plus encore de contrer.

Et pourtant, il avait raison ! Ils avaient tort, il avait raison. Il fallait défendre les évidences, les platitudes, les vérités. Les truismes sont vrais, accrochons-nous à cela ! Le monde physique existe, ses lois ne changent pas. Les pierres sont dures, l’eau est liquide, tout objet lâché est attiré par le centre de la terre.

Avec le sentiment de s’adresser à O’Brien, et aussi d’énoncer un axiome important, Winston écrivit : La liberté est la liberté de dire que deux et deux …

53 editions

reviewed Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell (The Complete works of George Orwell -- v. 1)

Review of 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' on 'Goodreads'

5 étoiles

The contributions of this book are far too grand for me to go into all details here. To make it short, I believe that Orwell provided a fitting explanation of how individual thought is suppressed under totalitarian regimes. The principles of doublethink are also used in democratic states whenever it is politically necessary to hold two conflicting opinions. I even claim that it is a politician's most essential skill to perform this mental gymnastics convincingly.

However, this propaganda does not necesarrily manage to convince everybody. Regardless of the political system, it seems that generally, the people under its influence tend to root for it. But also regardless of the system, the capacity for subversive ideas can never be eliminated. Whether this capacity is actually of any use, though, depends on the system. The dystopian world of 1984 deals with subversive thoughts in such an efficient way, that revolutionary spirit is …

reviewed Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell (The Complete works of George Orwell -- v. 1)

Review of 'Nineteen Eighty-Four' on 'Storygraph'

5 étoiles

There are a few things that I find riveting in 1984:
- The idea that information control can shape reality. I first read 1984 in college, before algorithms played such a huge role in our lives. Today the notion that influencing information access can shape a populations' perception of the world, encourage opinion, shape our behaviors is all too real.
- The sense of hopelessness is absolute. I've never felt so mournful finishing a book. At the end, the world of individual liberty and hope has just completed fading from view. As Winston capitulates, the state continues its inexorable march to consuming the whole of the human experience, subverting romantic relationships, subverting the relationship between children and parents, even purging language of unorthodox concepts.

I probably shouldn't read books like this on the road. What a downer.