Alex Cabe a publié une critique de Dreadnought par April Daniels
Pure Power Fantasy for Girls Who Could Really Use One
5 étoiles
There were a lot of familiar superhero tropes here, but the protagonist was from such an underrepresented perspective that everything felt fresh.
In interviews, Daniels will directly say this is a power fantasy to make trans girls feel strong, and Dreadnought sticks to that mission. However, Daniels resists the temptation to give her hero a perfect transition, and she deals with both fantasy and down to earth versions of realistic struggles.
It's always tricky to create a new superhero continuity from scratch. It's easy to see the fingerprints of Marvel and DC, and difficult not to feel like you're reading the store brand. The most successful attempts, like the Incredibles, stay tightly focused on the central characters. Daniels (mostly) succeeds here, but I'll be interested to see how the world evolves as the focus broadens a bit.
Looking forward to the second book (already in my Kindle) and hope we …
There were a lot of familiar superhero tropes here, but the protagonist was from such an underrepresented perspective that everything felt fresh.
In interviews, Daniels will directly say this is a power fantasy to make trans girls feel strong, and Dreadnought sticks to that mission. However, Daniels resists the temptation to give her hero a perfect transition, and she deals with both fantasy and down to earth versions of realistic struggles.
It's always tricky to create a new superhero continuity from scratch. It's easy to see the fingerprints of Marvel and DC, and difficult not to feel like you're reading the store brand. The most successful attempts, like the Incredibles, stay tightly focused on the central characters. Daniels (mostly) succeeds here, but I'll be interested to see how the world evolves as the focus broadens a bit.
Looking forward to the second book (already in my Kindle) and hope we get the third someday.