Reviews and Comments

Martin Kopischke

kopischke@bookwyrm.social

A rejoint ce serveur il y a 4 années

Purveyor of finest boredom since 1969. Lost causes catered for. He / him (they / them is fine, too). English / deutsch / français. @kopischke@mastodon.social (@kopischke on BirdSite)

My ratings can look harsh, because they do not reflect how much I enjoyed a book; instead, I try to assess how exceptional a piece of literature I find it. I quite like a lot of books I “only” rate three stars, and I wouldn’t necessarily enjoy re-reading everything I rate above that, but the only service I use which helps me express that kind of nuance is Letterboxd.

For reference: ★★★★★ Flawless 
★★★★☆ Must read 
★★★☆☆ Above average 
★★☆☆☆ Oh, well
 ★☆☆☆☆ Blargh

Avatar by Picrew Shylomaton, courtesy of @Shyle@mastodon.social

This link opens in a pop-up window

Sue Burke: Semiosis (EBook, 2018, HarperVoyager) 4 étoiles

In this character driven novel of first contact by debut author Sue Burke, human survival …

Great idea, poor execution

2 étoiles

A multigenerational story of mankind having to become symbiotic with life forms beyond its understanding to survive, this is marred by pedestrian prose, a narrative structure that leaves no room for characters to feel for, and a take on an alien, vegetable life form that has all the charm of a chemistry lesson. Read Children of Time if you like the idea done well.

Becky Chambers: The galaxy, and the ground within (2021) 5 étoiles

With no water, no air, and no native life, the planet Gora is unremarkable. The …

One for the heart

4 étoiles

Chambers’ Wayfarers cycle, of which this ostensibly is the last instalment, is the rare kind of SF that works its magic though the heart more than through the brain. The story of five aliens marooned, for a little while, on what is, essentially, an intergalactic road stop, will make you cry over a smile, rekindle your belief in humanity (even if nary a human plays a part) and, at times, laugh out loud (apparently, the matter of cheese is the most befuddling issue aliens would have with humankind). Or at least it made me do so.

reviewed Symbiosis by Nicky Drayden (Escaping Exodus, #2)

Nicky Drayden: Symbiosis (EBook, 2021, Harper Voyager) 3 étoiles

Nearly a thousand years removed from Earth, the remnants of humanity cling to existence inside …

This one is bursting at the seams

3 étoiles

In her closing notes, Drayden speaks of what an uphill battle finishing this novel was; sadly, that shows. While her universe of human colonies living parasitically inside vast spacefaring beasts is as wildly and immersingly imaginative as ever, this reprise of Escaping Exodus suffers from halting character arcs, choppy pacing and a deus ex machina resolution that lets whole plot threads dangling.