Alex reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
Fantastic
5 étoiles
I feel like the less I describe this the better. This gets my most enthusiastic recommendation.
paperback, 736 pages
Publié 14 septembre 2021 par HarperLuxe.
Monica Byrne: The Actual Star (2021, HarperLuxe)
- ISBN :
- 978-0-06-311788-4
Copied ISBN!
5 étoiles
(7 critiques)
Robert Fromont reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
A braided tale spanning millenia
5 étoiles
Three societies at three moments in time: a Mayan kingdom in decline in 1012CE, modern day capitalist society at the rollover of the Mayan calendar's 'long count' cycle in 2012, and 'Laviaja', a post-climate-change wanderer society of 3012CE.
If you liked Cloud Atlas's cast of characters popping up in different ages, you'll like the braided structure of this novel. In each strand, a small cast of characters face abandonment, alienation, and the yearning to escape.
If Ursula Le Guin's 'Birthday of the World' left you yearning for more, you'll love Byrne's 1012CE strand, as teenage twin monarchs rise to power in a declining kingdom bathed in animal gods, bloody rituals, and sacred places.
If you ponder #PostColonialism, #CulturalAppropriation, or you've ever been a privileged white tourist on a guided tour to an ancient place, there's something in the 2012CE strand for you. It follows the sordid misadventures of a misfit …
Three societies at three moments in time: a Mayan kingdom in decline in 1012CE, modern day capitalist society at the rollover of the Mayan calendar's 'long count' cycle in 2012, and 'Laviaja', a post-climate-change wanderer society of 3012CE.
If you liked Cloud Atlas's cast of characters popping up in different ages, you'll like the braided structure of this novel. In each strand, a small cast of characters face abandonment, alienation, and the yearning to escape.
If Ursula Le Guin's 'Birthday of the World' left you yearning for more, you'll love Byrne's 1012CE strand, as teenage twin monarchs rise to power in a declining kingdom bathed in animal gods, bloody rituals, and sacred places.
If you ponder #PostColonialism, #CulturalAppropriation, or you've ever been a privileged white tourist on a guided tour to an ancient place, there's something in the 2012CE strand for you. It follows the sordid misadventures of a misfit teenager on a quest to find spirituality and her place in the world.
If you wish Le Guin had leaned into the possibilities of anarchy more in The Dispossessed, or you shared the yearning for another world you found in #OctaviaButler's Earthseed, you'll love this novel's 3012CE strand. Like @pluralistic@mamot.fr's Walkaway, this novel projects utopia risen from dystopia. Global warming has come out in the wash. All our current problems are solved. Everyone just wanders the earth, going where they want, doing what they want. But new religion gives rise to new heretics.
If you were irresistibly drawn to the excruciating claustrophobic dread of The Tombs of Atuan (or even the arachnophobic nightmare of the Peruvian temple in Indiana Jones' iconic debut), you'll cower exquisitely before one of the novel's eternal protagonists: the sacred cave of Actun Tunichil Muknal.
But the millennia spanned also affords a long perspective for exploring the arc of humanity; family and social norms, the distinctions that generate prejudice, and even an interesting take on privacy and surveillance. I liked this a lot, and think it will stand a second reading.
joachim reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
Engaging and enjoyable
4 étoiles
Three successive stories, told in interwoven chapters. Three visions of what Maya culture was, is and could be. One tale could be read like mesoamerican fantasy, one like contemporary magical realism and one like the best kind of utopian science fiction.
Tak! reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
The Actual Star
4 étoiles
This one gave me Cloud Atlas vibes.
It's set across three timelines: ancient Maya, contemporary, and 1000 years in the future - I enjoyed the future segments and worldbuilding the most.
I feel like one needs to have a solid grounding in latine culture to get the most out of this.
David Bremner reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
thought provoking, definitely worth reading, ending a bit too tidy.
4 étoiles
Content warning meta discussion of ending
This is an ambitious, genre bending book. It combines elements of magical realism with post apocalyptic science fiction. Probably the most important social contribution is implicit; it imagines a world after climate change, and makes that seem very real and very immediate. It is also full of interesting ideas about utopia and the nature of religion, and includes some thoughtful critiques of some of those ideas. For me the ending was too neat, and if I'm honest, a bit too mystical. That's a matter of taste of course, but I felt like it lost the important tension between the emotional and the intellectual that was the backbone of the rest of the book,
loppear reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
superb
5 étoiles
Deeply satisfyingly layered and interwoven, imagined Mayan/Belizean past and future solarpunk Earths, central struggles with violence and disagreement and revolt without compromising voluntary consent, paced like a jaguar moving through ruins.
Derek Caelin reviewed The Actual Star by Monica Byrne
Incredible
5 étoiles
I inhaled this book, and I loved it, and I'm not entirely sure how to process it.