Critiques et Commentaires

loppear

loppear@bookwyrm.social

A rejoint ce serveur il y a 4 années, 9 mois

Reading for fun, threads over the years of scifi, history, social movements and justice, farming, philosophy. I actively work to balance out the white male default in what I read, but have a long way to go.

He/they for the praxis.

Ce lien ouvre une nouvelle fenêtre

Sarah Gailey, Liana Kangas: Know Your Station (GraphicNovel, 2023, BOOM! Studios)

artistically skewering our tech oligarchs escape to space

What could have been a cute-bloody murder mystery with an underdog staff dealing with the overpuffed wealthy occupants of their space station and a sneaky AI sidekick... is all that but goes extra hard at solidarity and collective liberation. Fun.

Brandon Sanderson: Yumi and the Nightmare Painter (2023, Dragonsteel Entertainment, LLC)

Yumi comes from a land of gardens, meditation, and spirits, while Painter lives in a …

sweet and snarky

Entertaining early adult romance of extravagant differences. As I jump into a standalone story set in a larger universe, it's hard to judge if some of the author-character hand-waving is clever or cheap, and I know I found the concluding twist to be both, but I'll try another.

a publié une critique de The Invention of the Creek Nation, 1670-1763 par Steven C. Hahn

Steven C. Hahn: The Invention of the Creek Nation, 1670-1763 (Paperback, 2014, University of Nebraska Press)

struck by the already-fatally-disturbed post-contact life

Account of Creek/Muscogee villages and leaders balancing and negotiating between three colonial powers in and around central Georgia and Alabama. Gives reasonable agency and complexity to groups portrayed by colonial records as legible nations with clear hierarchy and allegiance. Already dependent on European trade, squeezed and transplanted and resettling on town sites previously wiped out by DeSoto's visits, the population pursues their own diverse political ends in the space between over the few generations covered, a bit narrower than I hoped even while it says it right there.

Bryant Simon: The Hamlet Fire (EBook, 2020, University of North Carolina Press)

"Just over twenty-five years ago, on the day after Labor Day, a chicken processing factory …

wide-swept labor history

Incredible labor history, focused intently on a single tragic factory fire in a small North Carolina town, but with chapters diving deep into the political, economic, and sociological history of why neoliberal American industry sought out and created internally colonized places of ever cheapened government, food, health, and lives. He even fit all that in the subtitle, bravo, highly recommended.

a publié une critique de Imperial Mud par James Boyce

James Boyce: Imperial Mud (2021, Icon Books, Limited)

estuaries as sites of abundance, resilience, and resistance

Has more than I care about the English Civil War, but the thesis is strong: the productive marsh fens supported an independent and insurgent indigenous population until commons enclosure and agricultural systematization and a need for wage-dependent labor drove the state to drain and eradicate the communities and ecosystem.

a publié une critique de Infinity Gate par M. R. Carey (Pandominion, #1)

M. R. Carey: Infinity Gate (2023, Orbit)

"The Pandominion: a political and trading alliance of a million worlds. Except that they're really …

lots going on, either too precious or too late for the AI debate.

Fast multiverse combat adventure with a bunch of setup for... well, I'm a bit worried about whether this ever went anywhere beyond each next scene, there's a lot of incongruity in what we're shown to care about and what is plausible once the setting simultaneously covers one vs all and all vaguely-humanity vs all synthetic creation.

Steven C. Hahn: The Invention of the Creek Nation, 1670-1763 (Paperback, 2014, University of Nebraska Press)

To improve my historical sense of the pre-colonial land I live on (the author categorizes this as an "ethnopolitical history" of the development of Creek territorial identity as bordered by English, French, and Spanish colonies), and as an account of autonomous indigenous villages organizing a shared cohesive response to conflict.

a publié une critique de If Then par Jill Lepore

Jill Lepore: If Then (Hardcover, 2020, Liveright)

The Simulmatics Corporation, launched during the Cold War, mined data, targeted voters, manipulated consumers, destabilized …

Perhaps too mundane and oblique, but smartly done

Subtle - a history of early computer use in politics, following a mostly uninteresting and overconfident marketing company - Simulmatics - from '50s campaign analytics and simulation to Vietnam War psychological surveys and counterinsurgency to domestic riot prediction. Wherever she can, LePore tells this history from the perspective of the wives and secretaries of these blustering ad-and-war men, and with an eye to the parallel shadows and overpromises of current technology companies.

a publié une critique de Self-reliance, and other essays par Ralph Waldo Emerson (Dover thrift editions)

Ralph Waldo Emerson: Self-reliance, and other essays (1993, Dover Publications)

just Self-Reliance

Sharp rant on rejecting conformity and consistency with society or your past self, the wisdom of humanity we too easily revere in ancient and rare men is accessible to each of us by introspection and independent lived experience. Even with the theme's obvious early-US-individualism shortcomings in considering collective or interdependent life, this is a quality call for reset.