Critiques et Commentaires

loppear

loppear@bookwyrm.social

A rejoint ce serveur il y a 4 années, 5 mois

Reading for fun, threads over the years of scifi, history, social movements and justice, farming, philosophy. I actively work to balance out the white male default in what I read, but have a long way to go.

He/they for the praxis.

Ce lien ouvre une nouvelle fenêtre

A Brief History of Time: From the Big Bang to Black Holes is a book …

still fair to ask who this is for, now

By now well-covered only-so-popularizable territory of special relativity, black holes, expanding universe, quantum mechanics, anthropic principle, string theory, and does a reasonable job of remaining humble while inquisitive about the parts that might have no answer.

a publié une critique de Saving Time par Jenny Odell

Jenny Odell: Saving Time (Hardcover, 2023, Random House Publishing Group)

A radical argument that we are living on the wrong clock--one that tells us time …

somewhat a letdown

Less revelatory than her How To Do Nothing or Bridle's Ways of Being, the intent is there to re-examine the colonial capitalist and puritan influences on time's central role in living - our drive for efficiency, self-improvement, fixed hours and seasons - but even if the message is to de-focus, this is a scattered book. "The point isn't to live more, to but to be more alive in any given moment."

Charles Eshbach: From Sawmill to Sanctuary (Paperback, North Forty Publishing)

almost a zine, straight out of the 70s

Brief account by involved journalist of campaigning to save 200ac of old growth pines in the Keweenaw, raising local and state public awareness, negotiating and pressuring company and federal interests towards the goal of preservation, and encountering the natural wonder of the big tree ecosystem.

a publié une critique de The third desert par Fabrice Blée (Monastic interreligious dialogue series)

Fabrice Blée: The third desert (2011, Liturgical Press)

An inside historical perspective

Benedictines encounter Buddhists over the 20c and debate how to live hospitably in the world and balance a transition from monastic to missionary to peace-building. "The risk of religious isolation from dialogue is fundamentalism; to be religious is to be interreligious." Real peace is sustained encounter, not diplomatic negotiation.

a publié une critique de Bright Green Lies par Derrick Jensen

Max Wilbert, Derrick Jensen, Lierre Keith: Bright Green Lies (2021, Monkfish Book Publishing Company)

Save life on earth, or save industrial civilization?

Has the environmental movement shifted its goals from saving the earth's biodiversity, creatures, healthy ecosystems etc to arguing instead for the much-less-contentious saving of human industrial civilization with "green technology" promises of convenience, continued extraction, and ecological depletion? The book is a bit heavy on bashing the myths contained in how solar, hydro, recycling, cities, etc are not solutions to the root causes of extractive industrial consumptive convenience, but fair enough. Save life on earth, or save industrial civilization? It's a bit of a false bind, but it's also important to see when options marketed as "environmentally friendly" are mostly friendly to our continued inaction.

a publié une critique de The Red House mystery par A. A. Milne (Dover mystery classics)

A. A. Milne: The Red House mystery (1998, Dover Publications)

This is probably one of the top classics of "golden age" detective fiction. Anyone who's …

not much but entertaining

The mystery is fine, but the light amusement of the amateur sleuth and his enjoyment at his own cleverness in figuring it out all along the way is deftly delivered.

a publié une critique de Self-Renewal par John W. Gardner

John W. Gardner: Self-Renewal (Paperback, 2015, Echo Point Books & Media)

relevantly outflanked

Feels dated in that 60s way of clearly writing to a certain class of young men with shared values, but. Creativity and openness, learning balanced between innovation and continuity. Avoid the obligations of accumulation, renewal is a system property of individual social interactions to reject organizational tyranny, vested interests, and the conforming filtering of ideas and information in hierarchies.

a publié une critique de Flight ways par Thom Van Dooren (Critical perspectives on animals: theory, culture, science, and law)

Thom Van Dooren: Flight ways (2014)

"A leading figure in the emerging field of extinction studies, Thom van Dooren puts philosophy …

niche, thought-provoking

From the perspective of birds experience of extinction, these five case studies prompt deep questions about the more-than-human basis of caring, story telling and sense of place, mourning; about the intricacies of our entanglement with species around the world; in conversation with Haraway, how to live in discomfort with our best choices' complications.

Robin Wall Kimmerer: Gathering Moss (Paperback, 2003, Oregon State University Press)

Gathering Moss is a series of personal essays introducing the reader to the life cycle, …

Some of these are still finding her way, but the range is worth it

Essays of humor and humility and care, a sense of observation that stretches from the microscope to scientific inquiry to social obligation, and in a dozen different ways asks us to consider perspectives of place, belonging, and generosity from other being's vast or tiny differences. It's been a while since I read Braiding Sweetgrass, but I think this collection is no lesser for nominally having more of a narrow entryway through her world of moss.