Critiques et Commentaires

loppear

loppear@bookwyrm.social

A rejoint ce serveur il y a 4 années, 1 mois

Reading for fun, threads over the years of scifi, history, social movements and justice, farming, philosophy. I actively work to balance out the white male default in what I read, but have a long way to go.

He/they for the praxis.

Ce lien ouvre une nouvelle fenêtre

a publié une critique de Wages of rebellion par Chris Hedges

Chris Hedges: Wages of rebellion (2015)

"Revolutions come in waves and cycles. We are again riding the crest of a revolutionary …

Spoiler: the wages are likely prison, death, and haunting regret

Written after Occupy and before 2016 with deep appreciation for the economic inequality and carceral injustice pushing the US towards internal conflict, this reflects a non-violent realism about rebellion, repression, and vigilante-fascist state outcomes with historical analysis interviews - many from prison - with Black Panther, ANC, Nazi resistance, US whistleblowers, and Occupy activists.

a publié une critique de On Vicious Worlds par Bethany Jacobs (The Kindom Trilogy, #2)

Bethany Jacobs: On Vicious Worlds (Orbit)

The Jeveni have finally found freedom on the distant planet Capamame, delivered from Kindom oppression …

uncertain enjoyment when all loyalties fray,

The fast-paced intrigue and backstabbing continues grippingly. While the first book stood alone well enough, this is missing the arc and focus making its success hang much more on what may be to come.

a publié une critique de We Keep Us Safe par Van Jones

Zach Norris, Van Jones: We Keep Us Safe (2020, Beacon Press)

A groundbreaking new vision for public safety that overturns more than 200 years of fear-based …

just nice

A positive and caring transformation of safety and crime, focusing on minimizing harms (from capitalism, patriarchy, trauma too) over sensationalizing crime and "bad guys", moving to care from fear, and restorative justice' shift from punishment to accountability, all illustrated with personal and complicating stories.

a publié une critique de Pig Years par Ellyn Gaydos

Ellyn Gaydos: Pig Years (Hardcover, 2022)

This captivating memoir is a "startling testimony to the glories and sorrows of raising and …

a tentative voice with fresh experiences

Young farmhand accounts of rural hard work, near poverty in that solo youthful maybe it's still a choice way, animal life and death, and appreciation for visceral connections between plants, weeds, markets, seasons, and guts spilled on the ground.

a publié une critique de The Algebraic Mind par Gary F. Marcus

Gary F. Marcus: The Algebraic Mind (2001, The MIT Press)

dated and niche but good-hearted

From an era of toy-model connectionist AI 20 years ago, a set of critiques that still hold some weight in pointing to basic symbolic structure and relationships our thinking exhibits that spicy autocomplete may categorically still be struggling with. What's lovely about this book (which probably isn't relevant overall and anymore) is the generosity and curiosity the author gives to the other side, in exploring and expanding on the models he's critiquing he's also bridging language and concepts between subfields rather than jumping precipitously to disagreement.

a publié une critique de Slow Down par Brian Bergstrom

Kohei Saito, Brian Bergstrom: Slow Down (Astra House)

Why, in our affluent society, do so many people live in poverty, without access to …

growth will kill us faster, and marx maybe knew it too?

Two fascinating books smooshed together, neither what I was expecting, both earnest enough. First, a very readable light explanation that "green growth" and any ecological turn that leaves capitalism in place will be insufficient to avoid extractive exploitation beyond ecological limits we're facing. Second, a niche academic journey through Marx' years after Capital Vol 1 arguing from thin circumstance that he too realized some of the ecological necessities of degrowth rather than unerring progress. If that's what you needed to hear to slow down, well ok!

a publié une critique de Understory par Saneh Sangsuk

Mui Poopoksakul, Saneh Sangsuk: Understory (2023, Peirene Press, Limited)

A novel of man's relationship with nature, power, and the vitality of storytelling, from beloved …

lush & intense

Restless story telling swirling around a Thai monk recounting a long life. I found the first half's turbidity of time and perspective most engaging as a way of revealing memory and history of a place transforming from magical mysterious jungle, flowing into a more direct and unceasing narrative of human conflict with the powerful animals of the encroached forest.

Let Me Stand Alone (Hardcover, W. W. Norton, W.W. Norton & Co.)

One young woman’s voice―intense and poetic―grapples with universal ideas as it chronicles a personal journey …

hard choices, in hindsight

A beautiful collection of childhood writings to remember and witness a girl becoming an active resister for a more just world. Corrie's story moved me at the time of her death (in Gaza in 2003) as we are close in age and point of origin in Washington State, and this revisiting was made more poignant by the current war and by my now perspective as a parent considering the family's decision to put this together. For content, this is a varied set of childhood poems and journals and sketches, school essays and early college writing on relationships and local crisis care, and accelerating global anger with capitalism and involvement in the 2001-era anti-war movement.

Lily Brooks-Dalton: Good Morning, Midnight (Paperback, 2017, Random House)

Augustine, a brilliant, aging astronomer, is consumed by the stars. For years he has lived …

a first inverted and convoluted novel

I did not enjoy this as much as the subsequent The Light Pirate; similar themes of aging in disaster, the tenuousness of our ability to stay in communication and relation, and evocative desolate scenery, but with more convoluted and ultimately unnecessary and shaky setting and plot complications.

a publié une critique de Stardust Grail par Yume Kitasei

Yume Kitasei: Stardust Grail (2024, Flatiron Books)

Save one world. Doom her own.

From the acclaimed author of The Deep Sky comes …

inventive riffs on so many scales of space adventure

A delightful heist buddy crew against the odds space marines aliens in all configurations inscrutable galactic menace histories of oppression misunderstanding and hope. Also, a bit light and scattered.

a publié une critique de Rose/House par Arkady Martine

Arkady Martine: Rose/House (EBook, Subterranean Press)

Basit Deniau’s houses were haunted to begin with.

A house embedded with an artificial intelligence …

As spare translucent noir, I enjoyed it.

Each element is pristine and sun-baked here, like the setting: reluctant detective on the murder case, wealthy aesthetic recluse, mundanely dystopian AI. And as spare translucent noir, I enjoyed it.

Katherine Arden: The Warm Hands of Ghosts (Hardcover, 2024, Del Rey)

During the Great War, a combat nurse searches for her brother, believed dead in the …

Heartwrenching horrors of WWI

Compelled to return to the frontlines of madness, clawing for oblivion in the face of evils and devils, a glint of compassion and sanity from another human sharing the experience. Deftly haunting storytelling.