Critiques et Commentaires

Tak!

Tak@reading.taks.garden

A rejoint ce serveur il y a 3 années, 9 mois

I like to read

Non-bookposting: @Tak@glitch.taks.garden

Ce lien ouvre une nouvelle fenêtre

Yaroslav Barsukov: Sleeping Worlds Have No Memory

Refusing the queen’s order to gas a crowd of protesters, Minister Shea Ashcroft is banished …

Sleeping Worlds Have No Memory

I didn't enjoy this one, and I don't know if I can explain why. The whole thing has kind of a 70s scifi vibe (derogatory). The protagonist is shallow and self-serving, but not in an interesting way. There are interesting things about the world, but we barely explore them because we're chasing the dull protagonist. 🤷

Travis Baldree: Goblins & Greatcoats (EBook, Subterranean Press) Aucune note

A goblin with too many pockets and a disturbing affinity for cutlery, a rain-soaked night, …

Emet North: In Universes (2024, Cornerstone Publishing) Aucune note

For fans of Emily St. John Mandel and Kelly Link, a profoundly imaginative debut novel …

Ok, I made it through seven chapters, but this book is really not for me, in more ways than one.

Each chapter is a vignette of the protagonist's life in (apparently) a different parallel universe. Maybe they tie together in the end, I don't know. It doesn't help that I find the main character very unlikable in all her incarnations. It feels very inspired by Cloud Atlas, but not in a good way imo.

a publié une critique de A Drop of Corruption par Robert Jackson Bennett (Shadow of the Leviathan, #2)

Robert Jackson Bennett: A Drop of Corruption (2025, Del Rey)

The eccentric detective Ana Dolabra matches wits with a seemingly omniscient adversary in this brilliant …

A Drop of Corruption

A Drop of Corruption was a great followup to The Tainted Cup.

I love the universe, it's so delightfully weird and mysterious. Additionally, I appreciate that Din, despite being A Watson, actually does the majority of solving things and unraveling the story, instead of just floundering around until his Holmes solves everything.

a publié une critique de The Tomb of Dragons par Katherine Addison

Sarah Monette, Katherine Addison: The Tomb of Dragons (Hardcover, Tor Books)

Thara Celehar has lost his ability to speak with the dead. When that title of …

The Tomb of Dragons

The Tomb of Dragons is another solid Thara Celehar.

When I first read The Witness for the Dead, I was disappointed, because it had such different energy than The Goblin Emperor. After finishing The Tomb of Dragons, I went back to The Goblin Emperor again, but I actually stopped fairly quickly and went forward to Witness for the Dead instead, because this time what I wanted was the Thara Celehar energy. I have really come to enjoy how the pacing is very smooth and gradual, while being ultimately relentless. Celehar is never hurried or frantic - he just applies steady pressure to all his problems until they eventually crumble.

a publié une critique de The Ministry of Time par Kaliane Bradley

Kaliane Bradley: The Ministry of Time (Hardcover, 2024, Simon & Schuster)

In the near future, a civil servant is offered the salary of her dreams and …

The Ministry of Time

I really enjoyed The Ministry of Time.

I was frustrated with the protagonist for big chunks of the book for not realizing obvious things. The author repeatedly tried to defend this with "I bet you're thinking 'I would have realized this right away', but" and in a world where I know time travel exists, I absolutely would!

However, the writing is very good, and it kept me engaged. The combination of themes around time travel, colonialism, and refugee life really worked, and I feel like it allowed them to be explored from different angles.

I'm kind of let down by the inconclusiveness of the ending, but on the other hand they avoided most of the cliché time travel tropes, so overall I guess it balances out.

#SFFBookClub