Critiques et Commentaires

ju

ju@lire.boitam.eu

A rejoint ce serveur il y a 2 ans, 3 mois

Some SF, fantasy, and obscure LGBT, mixed with travel, photography theory and women authors, in French and English.

Ce lien ouvre une nouvelle fenêtre

a publié une critique de La légende de nos pères par Sorj Chalandon

Sorj Chalandon: La légende de nos pères (French language, 2009, Grasset, GRASSET) 4 étoiles

J'ai laissé partir mon père sans écouter ce qu'il avait à me dire, le combattant …

Un roman qui se lit d'une traite

4 étoiles

Un roman court et sinueux où l'auteur convoque à nouveau son père, la vérité, celle que l'on se dit, celle que l'on raconte et l'écriture. J'ai eu envie de me replonger dans ses romans après avoir écouté cette émission de France Culture : www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/serie-sorj-chalandon-le-juste-et-le-vrai Il y parle, comme dans ce roman, de trouver le mot adéquat, le mot juste, et c'est passionnant.

a publié une critique de A Stranger in Olondria par Sofia Samatar

Sofia Samatar: A Stranger in Olondria (EBook, 2013, Small Beer Press) 4 étoiles

Jevick, the pepper merchant's son, has been raised on stories of Olondria, a distant land …

A wonderful novel

5 étoiles

This is an ode to books, the power and poetry of words and stories, and it's gorgeously written, without pretention, in a way that takes the reader seriously and transports them instantly into the maze of the author's imagination. The world created isn't a typical western-middle-age fantasy world, it's strongly influenced by south asia, and north and east africa. If you're longing for something poetic and vivid, it's a rewarding read.

a publié une critique de The Warden par Daniel M. Ford

Daniel M. Ford: The Warden (2023, Doherty Associates, LLC, Tom) 3 étoiles

There was a plan.

She had the money, the connections, even the brains. It was …

A fun light read

4 étoiles

It feels like the author took his dream RPG and wrote it as a novel. There's magic, and of course, dwarfs and half-elves, wizards who need to sleep to recuperate all their capabilities, small side-quests leading to the big one, an engaging heroin and queer flavours added here and there. All in all, not revolutionary, but entertaining.

Alex White: A Big Ship at the Edge of the Universe (Paperback, 2018, Orbit) 3 étoiles

Furious and fun, the first book in this bold, new science fiction adventure series follows …

A weird mix of space opera and magic

3 étoiles

I wasn't sure what to expect, but the mix of classic space opera and magic was weird. There were fun moments, some action and a few relatable characters, but the worldbuilding was lacking (when you can't say for sure if a place is a planet or a city at the end of a book, maybe something is missing). Some characters were flat, and it also felt like there were discrepancies, notably with the vilain(s), their goal and motivation.

a publié une critique de The Last Watch par J. S. Dewes

J. S. Dewes: The Last Watch (Paperback, 2021, Tor Books) 4 étoiles

The Divide.

It’s the edge of the universe.

Now it’s collapsing—and taking everyone and everything …

Not a bad space opera, but...

4 étoiles

There are a few interesting elements in this classic premise of "a bunch of different people are stuck at the edge of the universe and must save it", and while the worldbuilding and powers at play aren't bad at all, there's just something missing. It isn't badly written either (although writers need to ban the words groaning/grunting forever), but again, it isn't very special. Not sure I'll dig in the second volume.

a publié une critique de Paname Underground par Johann Zarca

Johann Zarca: Paname Underground (Paperback, Français language, Goutte d'Or) 3 étoiles

Où s’arrête le réel, où commence la fiction ? Zarca raconte les coulisses du guide …

Virée underground qui reste en surface

3 étoiles

Je voulais lire un livre qui parle de Paris mais pas de St Germain des Prés et effectivement... Il y a le côté authentique de l'auteur, son maniement de l'argot et le goût de l'expérience vécue. Mais le trash fait aussi un peu épate-bourgeois.

Rachid Laïrèche: Il n'y a que moi que ça choque ? (Paperback, Français language, Les Arènes) 4 étoiles

Dans les rédactions, les journalistes politiques forment une communauté à part qui se retrouve tous …

Le journalisme politique vu de l'intérieur

4 étoiles

Une collection de moments, d'anecdotes et de réflexions personnelles tirée des 8 ans de journalisme politique de l'auteur. S'il n'y a rien de vraiment "croustillant" sur les politiques, l'auteur offre un point de vue intéressant sur ce monde en vase clos, chacun se renvoyant l'ascenseur ou se faisant des petites crasses, loin du quotidien des gens. Ce n'est pas un scoop, et probablement rien ne va changer après ce livre, mais c'est déjà un petit coup de pied dans la fourmilière.

a publié une critique de Palestinian Walks par Raja Shehadeh

Raja Shehadeh: Palestinian Walks (Paperback, 2008, Scribner) 5 étoiles

“A rare historical insight into the tragic changes taking place in Palestine.” —Jimmy Carter

From …

A poignant love letter to a land

5 étoiles

As heartbreaking and enraging as it is beautifully written, it is a must-read to understand the profound changes in the West Bank and occupied territories over the years. It had been on a sort of books-to-check-out list for years, I almost regret that I didn't read it sooner...

a publié une critique de These Burning Stars par Bethany Jacobs

Bethany Jacobs: These Burning Stars (2023, Orbit) 4 étoiles

On a dusty backwater planet, occasional thief Jun Ironway has gotten her hands on the …

Intriguing space opera

4 étoiles

Not a perfect debut novel, but a solid and intriguing space opera, full of cruel, coward and calculating characters, even though one important part felt deja vu (a powerful family controls the production of the substance that enables space travel...). All in all, it was an enjoyable read.